Log in

No account? Create an account
07 June 2008 @ 21:34
The Jane Austen Book Club  
The Jane Austen Book Club

The explosion of the "chick lit" phenomenon is probably largely to blame (if indeed this is blameworthy), but there's definitely been a resurgence in interest in Jane Austen in recent years. Off the top of my head, in the last decade or so we've had Bride & Prejudice, Pride & Prejudice, and Becoming Jane on the big screen, and of course the loosely Austen-based Bridget Jones movies. There have been countless television adaptations, and the BBC bio piece Miss Austen Regrets (far superior to Becoming Jane, I thought). Writer-director Robin Swicord's The Jane Austen Book Club (adapted from a novel by Karen Joy Fowler) is yet another Austen-themed film, albeit one taking quite a different tack from the others.

Book Club revolves around five women and one man who decide to form a book club where they will discuss each of Austen's six novels. Along the way, the characters' personal lives begin to loosely resemble scenarios in the novels they're reading. I thought this was a very cutesy premise, and I largely expected a frothy, cloying, and ultimately formulaic romantic comedy. In fact, I was pleasantly surprised, not by any lack of chick-flick convention, of which there was plenty, but by the overall thoughtfulness of the script and characterisations. Strong performances and well-written dialogue largely overshadowed the run-of-the-mill nature of many of the plotlines, resulting in a rare film, by Hollywood standards anyway.

The Jane Austen Book Club

Probably my favourite part of the film were the discussion scenes for the six novels because - not necessarily for the content of the discussion, but for the way they were written and performed. Although some of the discussion was very interesting and the characters made some keen observations, these nuggets were delivered in such short random bursts that the ideas were rarely fully explored. Yet that's exactly what I liked about it. Real group conversations have people throwing out various tidbits without any real structure, it's often choppy, and people constantly interrupt and cut each other off. The discussions in Book Club unfolded like real-life group conversations, and there was something satisfying about sitting back and eavesdropping on the characters' talks. Each characters' contributions to the discussion revealed pieces of themselves, and I felt like I wanted to jump in and have my say, too.

Also refreshing was the character of Grigg (Hugh Dancy), the lone male in the book club. Aside from being easy on the eyes and having an attractive penchant for showing up to book club in his cycling suit, Grigg is a very rare character in Hollywood film: a man that likes women. Obviously I'm not just referring to romantic interest; Grigg is a rarity because he actually enjoys the company of women and doesn't mind being the only guy in the group. And he's not gay. If Hollywood were to be believed, such men simply do not exist, which of course is completely ludicrous. Personally, I'm so bored of the man-bashing/woman-bashing, battle of the sexes nonsense that clogs so many romantic comedies, especially the tired way in which it's usually portrayed. Here's a novel concept, maybe men and women are not alien species and can in fact get along perfectly well and have intelligent, poignant discussions about literature, or whatever, without resorting to petty stereotyping. I'd like to think that this will set a trend and we won't have to watch the same beaten ground being trod on over and over, but this is probably wishful thinking.

There are lots of other little victories in Book Club. Allegra (Maggice Grace) is a lesbian who is neither a scary butch ballbuster nor a fetishized vixen - how many times has a character like her shown up in a conventional romantic comedy? Bernadette (Kathy Baker) is one of the most truly warm and compassionate characters I've encountered onscreen. In her short and sweet scenes she always manages to find the best in everyone she meets; her presence is uplifting and never overbearing.

My biggest sticking point (aside from the obvious "awwww" conclusions of some of the romantic plotlines) is the character of Prudie (Emily Blunt). On one hand, I was very impressed with Emily Blunt's performance of the painfully repressed Prudie (her name is the obvious clue). Blunt plays her with such carefully considered restraint that it hurts, and it's strange to encounter such a mannered, rigidly unhappy character in an otherwise freely emotional feel-good story. It really seems like Prudie is in the wrong film, and as such, her story is awkwardly out of place and feels the least believable. Severely chic with her prim pageboy bob and crisp minidresses, Prudie verges on being a character from something darkly erotic like Belle de Jour. Except that she's supposed to be a high-school teacher, which makes the whole simmering-sexuality-beneath-a-straitlaced-exterior thing really quite creepy. Don't get me wrong, I really like her wardrobe in the film, but I cannot imagine an actual high school teacher dressing like she does. I just really felt that Blook Club was totally the wrong film to address that topic. You can't just lightly play around with a teacher-student affair and then drop it without any real consequences, which is exactly what happens. Furthermore, with all the problems plaguing Prudie and her husband, would reading Persuasion aloud together really make all the hurt magically melt away? I think not.

Still, the good outweighs the highly questionable in Book Club, just as the (mostly) quality parts outweigh the squishy whole. The Jane Austen Book Club doesn't attempt anything revolutionary, but for an unassuming film about people discussing books, there are sizable chunks of the film working to break down stereotyping. Swicord is not necessarily always successful in doing so, but at least she made an effort not to produce empty fluff. The Austen angle is sweet, but to my surprise and delight, it was only a charming enytryway into the lives of some truly engaging characters.

The Jane Austen Book Club
. m u s i c .: Graham Coxon
stockdove on 10th June 2008 02:39 (UTC)
Fabulous review! I watched this movie quite a while ago so I don't remember all the gory details, but I have to admit that I really liked this movie. I think I might have even watched it twice. The characters really do stand out and seem to be a lot more realistic and interesting than what we typically see...their conversations are a lot more natural, which probably does have something to do with the quality cast also :) The name Allegra always makes me think of allergies though. I never really thought about it too much, but I completely agree with you that the Prudie Plot was slightly out of place in the film. The problem it tackles is just too intense and troubling to fit neatly into the movie. I do think it was well done though, at least the part with her and the student, when it came to resolving everything neatly and finding domestic bliss it was utterly ridiculous and laughable. Awww, and Grigg was absolutely fantastic, he was such a pleasure - just a genuinely warm, friendly, funny, sincere guy who sparkled with life :) And was extremely cute :) And thoughtful. Yay. I also hope that stereotypes will begin to wither away so that even mainstream films like this one will become much more enjoyable and satisfying. And now I have to confess that I really like the movie In the Land of Women, in which Adam Brody is highly enjoyable and the dialogue is kind of unusual in a refreshing way. And his grandmother is hilarious. Here's to fluff well done :)